Two clients. Same platform. Wildly different results.
I do tech support for online business owners, which means I get a front-row seat to what people think is broken.
And the number one thing I hear, by a mile, is: "My website isn't working."
So they rebuild it. New template, new colors, new layout. Weeks of work. They launch, hold their breath, and… crickets. So they assume the new version isn't good enough either, and start over.
I've watched people rebuild the same website three and four times, getting more discouraged each round, absolutely convinced the next version will finally be the one.
Let me tell you about two clients instead.
The five-year homepage
The first spent five years perfecting her homepage.
I mean that literally. She adjusted the hero image. Rewrote the headline. Moved sections around. Changed her colors, then changed them back. Every time we talked, she was refining something.
In five years, she never made a dime.
The six-figure business with no homepage at all
The second client made six figures without a homepage.
Not a bad one. Not a simple one. She didn't have one.
What she had was the CRM and a handful of quick sales pages. She knew exactly who she was talking to and what she was offering, she made real invitations, and she sent people directly to a page where they could say yes.
No hero image. No perfect fonts. No brand palette agonized over for months.
Same platform. Same tools available to both. The difference wasn't design, it was functionality and clarity.
What's actually happening when a site "doesn't work"
Here's what I usually find: the site is fine. The design is clean, the buttons work, the pages load.
But someone lands on it and can't tell in five seconds who it's for, what problem it solves, or why they should care.
No amount of redesign fixes that, because it isn't a design problem. It's a clarity problem wearing a design problem's clothes.
The harder version, which saved me years of my own life: websites don't generate traffic, and they don't create clarity. They display it.
If the thinking underneath is scattered, a prettier site just displays scattered thinking more attractively. You've spent six weeks making your confusion look nicer.
Why we blame the website
This isn't a knock on anyone, I did it too for years. There's a reason it's the default assumption.
The website is visible. It's a thing you can point at, fix, and feel productive about. Rearranging a page gives you a genuine sense of progress. You can see it changing.
Clarity is invisible. It's sitting with uncomfortable questions like "who is this actually for?" and "what do I actually believe?" questions with no template, no tutorial, and no satisfying visual payoff.
So of course we pick the visible thing. It feels like work. It just isn't the work that's blocking you.
And there's a second reason, quieter than the first: a website redesign is a project with an end. Clarity risks exposing that you're not sure what you're selling, or to whom. Rebuilding is safer than admitting that.
The five-second test
Open your homepage and read it as a complete stranger, someone who's never heard of you and has about five seconds of patience.
Can they tell:
- Who this is for? Specifically. Not "everyone," not "women." One type of person.
- What problem it solves? In their words, not your industry's words.
- What to do next? One obvious action. Not seven.
If any of those are fuzzy, you found your fix. And the good news is that it's a writing fix, not a building fix. You don't need a new template. You need clearer sentences, which you can write this afternoon for free.
The other half nobody mentions
Even a perfectly clear website won't do anything if nobody sees it.
My own site sat live for years and got almost no visitors unless I personally sent someone there. That's not a failure of the site — that's just what websites are. Websites are the destination. You are the traffic.
So run the two checks in order. Is the message clear enough that a stranger gets it in five seconds? And is anyone actually being invited to come look?
Fix those two and the website you already have will probably do just fine.
Try this today: run the five-second test
Open your homepage. Read it like a stranger. Set an actual timer if you want to be honest with yourself.
If you can't answer all three questions, don't open your page builder. Open a blank document and write clearer sentences instead.
That's the whole fix, and it costs nothing but the willingness to look at the harder problem.
If the five-second test didn't go well, the problem is upstream. Grab the free One-Page Brand Blueprint — who you help, what you believe, and what you consistently talk about, all on one page in about 20 minutes.
About the Author:
Julie Lewis
Nutrition Coach | Gamification Expert | Online Business Strategist | Tech Explorer
Julie helps solopreneurs turn grind into flow — building momentum in life and business using the science of engagement. [More about the FROG method →]
0 Comments